Pecan or Sweet Potato? North Carolina’s Holiday Pie Rankings Explained
In North Carolina, holiday traditions are deeply rooted in family gatherings, festive meals, and timeless desserts. Among the standout stars of these celebrations is pie. For years, High Point University’s annual pie poll has captured the state’s collective sweet tooth, and for the fourth consecutive year, pumpkin pie reigns supreme.
The 2024 High Point University poll sheds light on North Carolinians’ love for pies. Pumpkin pie leads the way with 24% of respondents naming it their top choice. Pecan pie comes in second at 18%, closely followed by sweet potato pie at 17%, and apple pie at 15%.
Interestingly, these rankings have remained relatively stable over recent years. In the 2023 poll, pumpkin pie also led with 24%, while pecan and sweet potato pies vied for second place at 17% and 16%, respectively. Apple pie trailed at 15%, proving its steadfast, if slightly lesser, popularity.
Whether it’s the velvety smoothness of pumpkin, the caramelized richness of pecans, or the earthy sweetness of sweet potatoes, each pie brings its own story and significance to holiday tables.
The allure of pumpkin pie
Pumpkin pie’s dominance in North Carolina is no mistake. This dessert epitomizes the flavors and spirit of the holiday season, evoking warmth and nostalgia. Its creamy, spiced filling, often served with a dollop of whipped cream, embodies a perfect balance of sweetness and aromatic spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.
Cultural and seasonal factors also play a role in its appeal. Pumpkins are deeply associated with fall and harvest festivals, aligning seamlessly with Thanksgiving and Christmas traditions. The pumpkin pie’s accessibility and versatility make it a go-to choice for home bakers and professional chefs alike.
Moreover, North Carolina’s agricultural history contributes to this preference. The state’s farm-to-table movement has fostered an appreciation for locally sourced ingredients, and pumpkins are often highlighted in this context.
The runners-up
While pumpkin pie claims the spotlight, pecan and sweet potato pies are equally celebrated in North Carolina homes. Pecan pie, with its buttery filling and crunchy, caramelized topping, captures the Southern penchant for indulgent flavors. Often made with locally grown pecans, this pie is a tribute to the region’s agricultural abundance.
Sweet potato pie, on the other hand, is a uniquely Southern delicacy. With its smooth, earthy filling, it offers a less spiced but equally rich alternative to pumpkin pie. For many families, sweet potato pie is a cherished recipe passed down through generations, symbolizing comfort and heritage.
Apple pie, while trailing slightly in the rankings, is still a quintessential American dessert. Its appeal lies in its simplicity—tart apples, a buttery crust, and a touch of sugar and spice.
Holiday pie traditions in the South
In the Southern United States, desserts are more than just the end of a meal—they’re a cultural experience. Pies, in particular, hold a special place in holiday traditions, symbolizing warmth, family, and festivity. North Carolina is no exception, showcasing a blend of Southern culinary staples and local influences.
Pumpkin, pecan, and sweet potato pies are integral to Southern holiday celebrations, reflecting the region’s agricultural heritage. Pecans, grown abundantly across the South, make pecan pie a natural choice. Similarly, sweet potatoes—a key crop in North Carolina—find their way into everything from casseroles to the beloved pie.
But it’s not just about the ingredients. Southern holiday pies often carry a personal touch, with recipes tweaked and perfected over generations. From flaky homemade crusts to secret spice blends, these pies are as much about family pride as they are about flavor.
As North Carolina’s culinary landscape evolves, holiday pie preferences may shift in subtle yet intriguing ways. For instance, the rise of artisanal and gourmet desserts could inspire more experimental takes on classic pies. Additionally, an increasing focus on health-conscious eating might lead to lighter, plant-based versions of traditional pies.
The enduring popularity of pumpkin, pecan, and sweet potato pies speaks to their deep-rooted significance in North Carolina’s holiday culture. Even as modern twists emerge, the essence of these classics is unlikely to fade, ensuring their place on holiday tables for generations to come.
Sources:
To keep up-to-date with our latest food industry news, subscribe to our newsletter today.